Rusty Spike

Rusty Spike

A straightforward yet flavorful variation of the classic Rusty Nail, substituting bourbon for Scotch to create a distinctly American character with sweeter, fuller-bodied notes.

43%

ABV

192

Calories

Rocks

Glass

Flavor Profile

Flavor Journey

6
Sweet
1
Sour
2
Bitter
7
Strong

History & Heritage

The Rusty Spike emerged organically as a natural variation of the Rusty Nail during American whiskey's cultural renaissance, with no singular documented origin. As the Rusty Nail (Scotch and Drambuie) gained prominence in the mid-20th century as a Rat Pack favorite, it was inevitable that bartenders would experiment with substituting bourbon for Scotch. The "Spike" name likely nods to the "Nail" in the original while suggesting a more "American" character. This represents the ongoing dialogue between American and Scottish whiskey traditions, using quintessentially Scottish Drambuie with America's native bourbon spirit. While never achieving the widespread fame of its Scotch-based counterpart, the Rusty Spike has seen renewed interest with the craft cocktail movement as a way to introduce bourbon drinkers to the classic Rusty Nail flavor profile.

Ingredients

Quality ingredients make all the difference. Each component plays a crucial role.

Method

Technique transforms ingredients into something extraordinary.

1

Fill Old Fashioned glass with a large, clear ice cube

2

Pour bourbon and Drambuie directly over the ice

3

Stir gently for 10-15 seconds to combine and chill ingredients

4

Express oils from lemon twist over surface and drop in glass

Glassware

Rocks

Served on the rocks in a classic Old Fashioned glass

Garnish

Lemon twist

Express oils over drink surface to cut through richness and add aromatic lift

Master's Tips

Professional insights to elevate your craft

Choose bourbon with at least 90 proof (45% ABV) to stand up to Drambuie

High-rye bourbons provide spicy counterpoint to sweet Drambuie

Large, clear ice cube minimizes dilution while maintaining chill

Don't skip the lemon twist - its oils are essential for balance

Variations & Riffs

Classic cocktails inspire countless variations. Here are some popular riffs on the Rusty Spike.

Other Variations

The 1:1 Rusty Spike

Minor Tweak

Equal parts bourbon and Drambuie for a sweeter, more liqueur-forward profile.

Changes
High-Rye Bourbon (90-100 proof):2 oz1.5 oz
Drambuie:0.8 oz1.5 oz

The Dry Spike

Minor Tweak

3:1 or 4:1 bourbon to Drambuie ratio for a drier, more bourbon-centric drink.

Changes
High-Rye Bourbon (90-100 proof):2 oz2.5 oz
Drambuie:0.8 oz0.6 oz

Rusty Nail (Original)

Major Variation

The classic Scotch whisky version that inspired the Rusty Spike.

Changes
High-Rye Bourbon (90-100 proof)Scotch Whisky(2 oz)

More to Explore

If you enjoyed this cocktail, these similar creations might capture your interest.